Skip to content
HotelTonight logo
Where
When
Tonight
Customize
1 room
Watch This Search
We’ll email you pricing updates
The Pridwin
Charming
DAILY DROP

The Pridwin

98% | 
 – Long Island
per night
A dreamy Shelter Island resort that is only accessible by ferry offers direct beach access and endless opportunities to sit back and relax.
The Andrew Hotel
Basic
DEAL

The Andrew Hotel

84% | 
 – Great Neck
per night
Soft & comfortably minimalist rooms are like that fave pair of jeans that’s broken in just right.
The Garden City Hotel
2 rooms left
Luxe

The Garden City Hotel

93% | 
 – Garden City
per night
Traditional style honors the hotel's historic past – it's been in operation since way back in 1874.
Three Ducks
Solid

Three Ducks

94% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Airy guestrooms rock vaulted ceilings and a soothing, nature-inspired vibe, plus mini-fridges and Flamingo Estate toiletries.
Journey East Hampton
2 rooms left
Charming
DEAL

Journey East Hampton

92% | 
 – East Hampton
per night
Brand new rustic hideaway, with a spot-on location between East Hampton and Amagansett. Also: private pool(!).
American Beech
2 rooms left
Hip
DEAL

American Beech

95% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Bearing the name of the 75-year-old tree in the center of Greenport Village’s central square, and just as beautiful.
Red Roof PLUS+ Long Island – Garden City
Basic

Red Roof PLUS+ Long Island – Garden City

83% | 
 – Westbury
per night
A mere mile to the LIRR, making for easy, car-free Long Island adventuring.
The Roslyn, Tapestry Collection by Hilton
Solid

The Roslyn, Tapestry Collection by Hilton

90% | 
 – Roslyn
per night
Beautiful building, modern rooms, friendly staff and convenient location — everything you could need!
Hampton Inn Farmingdale
Basic

Hampton Inn Farmingdale

99% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Conveniently located just 3 miles from local attractions like Bethpage Black Golf Course and Farmingdale State College.
Harpoon House Hamptons
1 room left
Hip

Harpoon House Hamptons

88% | 
 – Long Island
per night
In the mood for a leisurely lunch? Look no further than the hotel’s own eatery.
Days Inn Woodbury
Basic
DEAL

Days Inn Woodbury

85% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Hey hey, free breakfast every day.
Holiday Inn Long Island Islip Arpt East
Solid

Holiday Inn Long Island Islip Arpt East

93% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Well-connected home base 8 miles from the airport and 5 from Ronkonkoma station (LIR) – plus a free shuttle to both.
La Quinta Inn Ste ISP AP
Basic

La Quinta Inn Ste ISP AP

84% | 
 – Bohemia
per night
Complimentary breakfast kick-starts both your metabolism and your day.
Homewood Suites Carle Place Garden City
1 room left
Basic

Homewood Suites Carle Place Garden City

92% | 
 – Carle Place
per night
Convenient spot near Belmont Park and Nassau Coliseum. (But first, grab some hot breakfast – it’s on the house.)
Marram Montauk
2 rooms left
Luxe

Marram Montauk

91% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Revel in the oceanside pool, house cruiser bikes and bath amenities from Le Labo.
Barlume Beach
1 room left
Solid

Barlume Beach

 – Long Island
per night
Set along Montauk Harbor, this lively retreat is home to a beach club, marina & 19-room boutique hotel.
Inn At Great Neck, BW Premier Collection
2 rooms left
Solid

Inn At Great Neck, BW Premier Collection

90% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Primo spot on the Gold Coast, strolling distance to antique shops, boutiques, galleries and restaurants.
Hotel Indigo LONG ISLAND - EAST END
Solid

Hotel Indigo LONG ISLAND - EAST END

96% | 
 – Riverhead
per night
Chic and comfortable starting point for exploring Long Island's eastern beach towns.
The Penny Lane
1 room left
Basic

The Penny Lane

 – Long Island
per night
Bring your furry friends along for the ride. This place is pet friendly.
Chalet Inn & Suites Centerport
Basic

Chalet Inn & Suites Centerport

85% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Inviting rooms rock daily housekeeping and free WiFi. Beds too, but that’s pretty much a given.
Hero Beach Club
Hip

Hero Beach Club

94% | 
 – Montauk
per night
Nature-y setting across from a moon-shaped stretch of beach, with hiking trails in every direction.
EVEN Hotel Long Island City - New York
Solid

EVEN Hotel Long Island City - New York

88% | 
 – Long Island
per night
In the mood for a leisurely lunch? Look no further than the hotel’s own eatery.
The Sagaponack
1 room left
Basic

The Sagaponack

93% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Want to be close to nature? Then come hide out on our charming 6-acre property!
Topping Rose House
Luxe
DEAL

Topping Rose House

96% | 
 – Bridgehampton
per night
This Greek revival mansion fosters a classic-contemporary vibe with mid-century furnishings and original modern art.
Holiday Inn Plainview Long Island
Solid

Holiday Inn Plainview Long Island

86% | 
 – Plainview
per night
Right off the Long Island Expressway, 30 miles from Manhattan.
Montauk Yacht Club
Luxe

Montauk Yacht Club

92% | 
 – Montauk
per night
Stretch those Jitney-cramped legs in spacious, beach cottage-inspired guestrooms. Arrive by boat? The 232-slip marina awaits.
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge
Basic

Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge

89% | 
 – Hauppauge
per night
Just a block off the LIE, but still a comfy, quiet spot to lay your head at night.
The Montauk Beach House
Hip

The Montauk Beach House

92% | 
 – Montauk
per night
We are never too exhausted for a 3-min walk to the beach.
Holiday Inn Westbury
Basic

Holiday Inn Westbury

87% | 
 – Carle Place
per night
Nearby destinations (some even walkable) keep evvvvveryone happy, from golfers to shoppers.
Seven Beach Lane
1 room left
Charming

Seven Beach Lane

94% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Just off of Westhampton’s charming main drag, a short stroll to bakeries, eateries, and boutique shops.
Southampton Long Island Hotel
1 room left
Basic
DEAL

Southampton Long Island Hotel

90% | 
 – Long Island
per night
Minutes from the famous Cooper’s Beach. Sunscreen up and go!